Gender-Affirming Medical Care
By Dr. Shayne Reitmeier
The Complaints Committees recently reviewed several cases involving the care provided to 2SLGBTQ peoples. CPSM recognizes that issues of sexuality and gender are complex and not everyone will yet be familiar with various terms. CPSM expects that all registrants provide respectful care to all patients regarding their sexuality and gender.
An Introduction to Sexuality and Gender
An inclusive approach starts with understanding terminology. Table 1 provides a breakdown of the 2SLGBTQ acronym, and Figure 1 is a playful yet illustrative educational tool to assist a deeper understanding of sexuality and gender.
Sexuality
Physicians should view sexuality as a combination of both romantic and sexual attractions. These attractions are based on continuums, meaning a patient may be attracted to women/females/femininity, men/males/masculinity, both, or neither.
Gender
Gender is not just the genitalia seen a birth. Instead, we can look at gender as a combination of identity and expression. Gender identity is how you perceive, express, and value your gender- How you think of yourself. Gender expression is how you perform your gender identity which relates to your characters, behaviours, and appearance- What you show to the world. Gender is constructed with varying levels of masculinity and femininity, which are not mutually exclusive. This allows for gender to have a much broader definition and creates an environment where a patient may express their gender in a more fluid manner.
Barriers Faced by the 2SLGBTQ Community
Attitudinal Barriers |
When a person or group thinks or acts on false assumptions |
Example |
Homophobia, heterosexism, heterocentrism, and racism |
Technological Barriers |
Limited access to relevant and useful hardware and software |
Example |
Electronic Health Records without intuitive option to differential gender and sex assigned at birth |
Systemic Barriers |
The result of practices, policies and procedures that result in unequal access or blatant exclusion, of a person or community. |
Example |
Lack of provider skill or knowledge, access limitations, gaps in language and literacy |
Physical Barriers |
Structural obstacles without our environment |
Example |
Female OR male bathrooms, gendered health clinics |
Why is this so important?
The compounded effect of the above barriers results in an increase in negative health outcomes including; anxiety, depression, substance use disorders, and chronic health conditions. The risk of suicide is alarming, as a recent Canadian study demonstrated that transgender youth are five times more likely to have suicidal ideation and are nearly eight times more at risk of a suicide attempt when compared to their cisgender heterosexual peers. (4)
What is Gender Affirming Care?
Gender-affirming care is a term used by healthcare providers who treat patients whose gender identity is not congruent with their sex assigned at birth. The goal for gender-affirming care is gender affirmation; where a person can thrive as their authentic self. The pursuit of gender affirmation frequently requires a combination of medical, psychological, and legal steps. In medicine, we often focus on the patient pursuing treatment to assist in developing secondary sexual characteristics that are reflective of their gender identity. While not everyone will have the knowledge to provide direct treatment in these circumstances, it is important to obtain referrals and support patients in their treatment goals.
What can we do?
1. Create a welcoming environment
Materials: Inclusive posters, stickers, reading material
Language: Inclusive and affirming language by all staff members
Forms: Include a space for both legal name and preferred name.
Include a space for both gender and sex.
Include a space for pronouns.
2. Make it a part of your routine
Introductions: Avoid assumed gender titles (ex: Sir, Miss, Mr, Ma’am).
Ask: Take a moment to ask every patient their preferred name and pronouns.
3. Be an effective ally
Being an ally requires action, being someone who is willing to provide visible and consistent support to the 2SLGBTQ community.
4. Apologize if you make a mistake
We all make mistakes. Be sure to acknowledge what went wrong, apologize, and move on. Saying “I’m sorry” can go a long way when building a therapeutic relationship.
Trans Health Resources and Referrals |
|||
RESOURCE:Click here to view information about Trans Health Klinic and resources for healthcare practitioners providing gender-affirming care. |
|||
Provider |
Location |
Phone |
Fax |
Dr. Christine Buchel |
Trans Health Klinic |
204-784-4090 Use eConsult for referrals |
204-784-4013 |
Dr. Robert Obara |
Trans Health Klinic |
204-784-4090 Use eConsult for referrals |
204-784-4013 |
Dr. Steven Melnyk |
Trans Health Klinic |
204-784-4090 Use eConsult for referrals |
204-784-4013 |
Dr. Catherine Guzman |
Trans Health Klinic |
204-784-4090 Use eConsult for referrals |
204-784-4013 |
Dr. Kelby Treloar |
Brandon Trans Health Clinic |
204-578-2516 |
204-578-2824 |
Dr. Shayne Reitmeier |
Portage Clinic and Teen Clinic |
204-857-3445 |
204-239-1278 |
Dr. Brandy Wicklow |
GDAAY (HSC)* |
204-787-7435 |
204-787-1655 |
Dr. Simon Trepel |
GDAAY (HSC)* |
204-787-7435 |
204-787-1655 |
Dr. Harpreet Gill |
GDAAY (HSC)* |
204-787-7435 |
204-787-1655 |
Dr. Kathrine Pundyk |
GDAAY (HSC)* |
204-787-7435 |
204-787-1655 |
Dr. Megan Cooney |
GDAAY (HSC)* |
204-787-7435 |
204-787-1655 |
*GDAAY only accepts referrals from primary care providers and only accepts youth ages 8-14 years old who meet specific criteria.
If you would like to be added to this list, please email communications@cpsm.mb.ca
Click here for a printable pdf of this post.
Citations:
(1) Reitmeier, SD. The Intersection of Transgender Health and Dermatology [Unpublished master’s dissertation]. Cardiff University, Wales. 2022.
(2) Killermann S. It's Pronounced Metrosexual. 2015 [accessed July 15 2022]. Available from: https://www.genderbread.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Breaking-throughthe- Binary-by-Sam-Killermann.pdf.
(3) World Professional Association for Transgender Health. 2012 [Accessed April 13 2022]. Available from: https://www.wpath.org/publications/soc.
(4) Kingsbury M, Hammond N, Johnstone F, Colman I. Suicidality among sexual minority and transgender adolescents: a nationally representative population-based study of youth in Canada. CMAJ. 2022; 194(22): DOI: https://doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.212054.